Soy Nut Butters?

Posted on: Mon, 10/08/2007 - 12:37pm
pennykandy's picture
Joined: 06/09/2004 - 09:00

Okay, so my DD (10) has only tasted PB 3 times, and they were all when she was less than 3 years old (2 of which resulted in trips to the ER). So she has no real idea what PB tastes like.

This week, one of her close classmates who has also been PA since she has known him has 'outgrown' his allergy. They found out when he accidentally ate something, and didn't react....further testing and food challenges resulted in the discovery that he is no longer allergic. Well he is loving his new found food choices and freedoms, and has apparently told DD how GOOOOOOD PB is!!!!

So, she is, understandably, wondering what she is missing. I have never bought fake peanut butter before, because I didn't want her to like it, and somehow accidentally get confused and eat the real thing. But now, I think she is old enough to know 'the rules' so to speak. So, today, I bought the only Soy nut butter the grocery store had. It was called 'I.M. Healthy Honey Creamy SoyNut Butter' and found in the natural food aisle (there were none in the peanut butter/jelly aisle) I have to say....this stuff smells like real peanut butter, but tastes more like....CLAY!!!! It's horrible!

After staring at the sandwich I made her for about 15 minutes (unable to believe that this sandwich was actually peanut free) she finally took a bite and hated it. Now, of course it may be that she would have hated it no matter what it tasted like just based on the fact that she's been trained to hate the smell, but....

My question is all Soy Nut Butters taste like clay? Or are there good alternatives that actually do taste more like PB?


Posted on: Mon, 10/08/2007 - 3:35pm
Peg541's picture
Joined: 12/29/2002 - 09:00

I never tasted soy nut butter but I did taste pea butter which still gives me nightmares. I think once you like Peanut Butter, the real thing, nothing will replace it. For me at least, probably not everyone.
Be careful because lots of those allergic to Peanuts are allergic to soy as well.

Posted on: Mon, 10/08/2007 - 9:57pm
momto4boys's picture
Joined: 06/06/2007 - 09:00

I also thought that soy butter were pretty bad. I even tried adding marshmallow fluff to it (not very healthy I guess) and that made it edible to my then 2 year old. I have since found Sunbutter and love it. My son likes it also. I do warn about confusion with PB (I will post in the reaction section about this). I had a horrible time trying to find a PB substitute for ME when DS was diag with PA and really like the Sun butter (especially the Honey Crunch - kids like creamy though). It is made from sunflower seeds and that is exactly what it tastes like. It doesn't taste like PB to me but works very well in the same appplications as PB. Hope this helps.

Posted on: Tue, 10/09/2007 - 12:09am
mom2boys1975's picture
Joined: 07/19/2007 - 09:00

My oldest ate PB almost every day before his younger brother was diagnosed with PA. I buy him sunbutter now which he eats 2-3 times per week. He seems to think it's a good substitute for PB. I think it kind of tastes like PB, but I think it has a funky after taste.
We tried soy butter too and we thought the sunbutter had a better taste. I get it at trader joes since I have yet to see anything like it at the supermarket.

Posted on: Tue, 10/09/2007 - 6:07am
gw_mom3's picture
Joined: 02/14/2000 - 09:00

Hmm I love soy nut butter. lol. And I used to be a pretty big PB eater. DD, who is PA/TNA likes it too. We've tried sunbutter but she prefers the soy.

Posted on: Wed, 10/10/2007 - 2:06am
mom0810's picture
Joined: 03/30/2007 - 09:00

I LOVE the IM Healthy soy butter. Guess it's just been a while since I had PB. :)

Posted on: Wed, 10/10/2007 - 10:02am
pennykandy's picture
Joined: 06/09/2004 - 09:00

Thanks everyone, I will see if I can find the sunbutter. I have a close friend who has offered to make her house peanut free as well...althought that's not something I would ask her to do. So she's looking for a good alternative too.

Posted on: Wed, 10/10/2007 - 8:27pm
JND's picture
Joined: 09/28/2004 - 09:00

I also don't like most soynut butters, except for Simple Foods soynut butter. We've only been able to get the cinnamon flavor, and we think it's great. We also LOVE sunbutter (both the Trader Joe's version and the original "Sunbutter" version). My PA daughter was thrilled to try it to see what PB tastes like.

Posted on: Wed, 10/10/2007 - 11:15pm
sidni's picture
Joined: 08/28/2004 - 09:00

I dont particularly like that IM Hleaht ysoy nut butter (although it works for baking)... There is a brand called Freenut butter (which is another soynutbutter) which is available in Canada and has a creamier consistency. One thing, though-- the IM healthy CHOCOLATE soynut butter is really good. it doesnt take like nutty anything, just... chocolatey. I am guessing it might be something like nutella, but I'm not sure.
personally, I have really grown to love PEABUTTER. My boyfriend was a peanutbutter FIEND before he met me and the peabutter has really been the only alternative that satisfies him. He says it reminds him a lot of the natural "health food store" peanut butter. My dad also loves PB but seems to have really taken a liking to the Sunflower seed butter.
Hope this helps!

Posted on: Thu, 10/11/2007 - 12:08am
mom2boys1975's picture
Joined: 07/19/2007 - 09:00

Where do you get pea butter? I am missing PB&J so bad and sun and soy butter just don't do it for me.

Posted on: Sun, 08/28/2011 - 10:49pm
kurtmahon's picture
Joined: 07/09/2011 - 07:56

I have seen a lot of good testimonials for Wowbuter on this site. Maybe you should give it a try.

Peanut Free and Nut Free Community

Click on one of the categories below to see all topics and discussions.

Latest Discussions

Latest Post by Italia38 Wed, 01/15/2020 - 11:03am
Comments: 10
Latest Post by Italia38 Wed, 01/15/2020 - 10:52am
Comments: 2
Latest Post by penelope Tue, 01/14/2020 - 1:03pm
Comments: 1
Latest Post by penelope Sun, 12/29/2019 - 6:21pm
Comments: 2
Latest Post by sunshinestate Sun, 12/29/2019 - 6:00pm
Comments: 3
Latest Post by Italia38 Sun, 12/29/2019 - 5:44pm
Comments: 5
Latest Post by justme Tue, 12/17/2019 - 3:41pm
Comments: 4
Latest Post by justme Tue, 12/17/2019 - 2:39pm
Comments: 45

Peanut Free Store

More Articles

If you have a food allergy, you will probably need to make some changes to your diet...

When love is in the air we can get caught up in the moment and throw caution to the wind. However, if you have a...

Do you have a child with peanut allergies and an upcoming birthday? Perhaps you'd like to bake a...

Many doctors treat allergies, including pediatricians and general practice doctors. When allergies are severe, primary care physicians often refer...

If you are looking for a way to support food allergy education and awareness, you may be interested in a documentary created by a young filmmaker...

The most frightening thing about a severe allergic reaction to a new food is that it can happen so fast. If parents are not looking for allergic...

Skin rashes and itching are common allergic reactions to peanut butter. According to the Mayo Clinic, reactions to peanut butter can happen within...

A low oxalate diet may be recommended to prevent kidney stones from forming. Oxalates are chemicals found in plant-based foods. These may collect...

So many wonderful recipes call for peanut butter. These recipes can still be enjoyed by experimenting with peanut butter replacements.


According to the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America, one out of five people in the U.S. has an allergy. Because there is a...

Hydrogenated vegetable oil sounds healthy because of the word "vegetable" in it. The truth is that it is not very healthy at all because it...

Foods with soy lecithin may need to be avoided if you have a soy allergy. Soy lecithin is present in many different foods. Since it is derived...

At some point in time, most people will suffer from food intolerance or a food allergy. Having an unpleasant reaction to something you have eaten...

The Jaffe Allergy Technique or Jaffe Mellor Technique (JMT) is an alternative approach to addressing symptoms of a variety of health issues, both...

Phenols found in healthy fruits, vegetables and grains could point to food allergies...

Allergies and anxiety are often experienced together, yet there is no scientific evidence that either condition causes the other. The enduring tie...

Tree nuts and peanuts are distinctly different. An allergy to one does not guarantee an allergy to the other. Peanuts are considered legumes and...

What can you eat if you can't eat peanut butter? Fortunately for people with a peanut allergy, there...

A few years ago, a 47-year-old Toronto woman received a lifesaving double-lung transplant. After the transplant, she suffered four anaphylactic...

Whether it's the holiday season, birthdays, or a dinner party, there's always a need for good gift ideas but it gets a bit more challenging when...